Chris Simms On Quinn Ewers' NFL Draft Stock: A Critical Examination

In a recent podcast appearance, Pro Football Talk analyst Chris Simms sent shockwaves through the NFL world by declaring that Ohio State quarterback Quinn Ewers has fallen out of the top ten in his 2024 NFL Draft rankings. This bold statement has sparked a flurry of debate, with many questioning Simms' reasoning and the implications it may have for Ewers' draft stock.

Assessing Simms' Claims

Simms' decision to downgrade Ewers is based on the quarterback's underwhelming performance in 2022. After a highly anticipated debut in which he threw for over 300 yards and two touchdowns, Ewers struggled to sustain that level of play throughout the season. He finished the year with a completion percentage of just 59.4%, an average of 206.5 passing yards per game, and six interceptions to eight touchdowns. Simms believes that Ewers' lack of consistency and decision-making errors are red flags that outweigh his physical tools.

Counterarguments and Data Points

However, it's important to note that Ewers played behind an inexperienced offensive line and was often under pressure. Additionally, the Buckeyes' offense was hampered by injuries, making it difficult for him to establish a rhythm. Despite these challenges, Ewers flashed signs of brilliance at times, showcasing his strong arm, mobility, and ability to throw with anticipation.

Statistical analysis also paints a different picture. According to Pro Football Focus, Ewers ranked ninth among FBS quarterbacks in big-time throw percentage (3.8%) and tenth in adjusted completion percentage (83.4%). These metrics suggest that he has the talent and accuracy to succeed at the NFL level.

Industry Perspectives and Draft Projections

While Simms' opinion carries weight, it's not the only one in the industry. NFL Draft analyst Dane Brugler of The Athletic still ranks Ewers as the top quarterback in the 2024 class, while Daniel Jeremiah of NFL Network has him at number two. Furthermore, several draft projections have Ewers going in the top ten, including ESPN's Mel Kiper Jr. and CBS Sports' Ryan Wilson.

Implications for Ewers' Draft Stock

Simms' comments may have a short-term impact on Ewers' draft stock, but it's unlikely to derail his NFL aspirations entirely. While it's true that NFL teams will scrutinize his performance in 2023, Ewers has the talent and pedigree to bounce back from a disappointing season. If he shows improvement in his accuracy, decision-making, and ability to play under pressure, he will remain a coveted prospect for teams in need of a franchise quarterback.

Conclusion: The Complexity of Draft Evaluation

The Chris Simms On Quinn Ewers debate underscores the complexities of NFL Draft evaluation. There is no single right or wrong answer, and the best approach is to consider a variety of perspectives, data points, and real-life examples. While Simms' concerns are valid, it's important to remember that Ewers is still a highly talented quarterback with upside. His draft stock may fluctuate based on his performance in 2023, but he has the ability to prove that he is worthy of being selected in the top ten.

Ultimately, the NFL Draft is not just about talent on paper. It's about projecting which players have the mental and physical makeup to succeed at the highest level. Quinn Ewers has the raw ability, but he must now show that he has what it takes to become an elite NFL quarterback. The 2023 season will be a crucial proving ground, and it will be fascinating to see how he responds to the challenges ahead.